PKMKII wrote:daftbeaker wrote:It would have gotten a bit religiony and turned into a modern day version of Narnia where the pure innocent must die for the original sin to be forgiven, the same way Aslan was the metaphor for Jesus.
Just because someone makes the ultimate sacrifice, doesn't mean they're necessarily a christ figure. If anything, the whole "we're in a metaphysical train station" bit smacked more of religion to me, than if Potter had just died, Voldemort marched back to Hogwarts, the fight went down and Longbottom killed the snake. Although, the fact that Rowling repeatedly referred to Potter as "The Chosen One" throughout the series made the religious metaphors inevitable.
Also, "the Boy Who Lived" has something in common with Moses (who lived when all the other unfortunate baby boys of his generation were executed --just to be safe -- by an evil overlord who did not want to be challenged later in the story) and Jesus (who lived when all the other unfortunate baby boys of his generation were executed -- just to be safe -- by an evil overlord who did not want to be challenged later in the story).





