Moderator: Other Stuff Mods
I agree with you in all aspects other than it being as good an adaptation as Harry Potter. Zack Snyder left out little in Watchmen, but with Harry Potter, it was like the director just stripped down everything but the basic plot. Sure, Snyder left out some of the most interesting bits, like the "word on the street" type thing with the Newstand vendor that provided a bit of context, but it was still a very good adaptation.Qwertyuiopasd wrote:I believe it was Tim Buckley who said it this way... It's a supplement to the comic.
Read the comic, then you get to watch the movie, and see (parts of) it acted out with wonderful visuals.
Seeing the movie by itself isn't going to be anywhere near as good. It's probably one of the best adaptation movies in the last 10 years. Not quite as good as LOTR, but perhaps of Harry Potter. Sure, there's some issues and things we'd rather they hadn't done, but all in all it's a good translation from text to screen.
Detective TurtleHolmes wrote:April 4: Went to Supanova, picked up the graphic novel of Watchmen. Saw four guys dressed as Rorschach. Took photos on phone. Got another photo with him. Can't show real face. Impostors are everywhere.
By the power invested in me by tabloid-reading imbeciles, I name you a pedo-dog!
Detective TurtleHolmes wrote:Hey, if anyone here is up to date in Naruto, (the manga) then one will notice correlations with the "grand plan" of Watchmen to that of Naruto. It's quite interesting.
No no no, don't be silly. Just that there is the possibility that Kishimoto Masashi stole the idea.fueledbycoffee wrote:Detective TurtleHolmes wrote:Hey, if anyone here is up to date in Naruto, (the manga) then one will notice correlations with the "grand plan" of Watchmen to that of Naruto. It's quite interesting.
You did not just compare the great Alan Moore to Naruto...
fueledbycoffee wrote:America has a long and hallowed tradition of irrational tax evasion and belligerence. We are the national equivalent of the Nac Mac Feegle. And we're the leaders of the free world. Damn, now I've scared myself shitless.
black bart wrote:I enjoyed the film thoroughly but the Graphic Novel is superb.
Shame they left the Pirate bit out in the movie but I guess that would have made the film too long.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest