straw-man fallacy

Published November 17th, 2006 by Bobby Henderson

Basic Straw-man Fallacy… They put up this stupid straw-man that nobody in their right mind would believe in(Pastafarian Religon) and then falliciously equate it to a real belief(Intelligent Design) that is supported by many scientists, in an attempt to refute that belief.

-vashsunglasses



811 Responses to “straw-man fallacy”

  1. Oarless Marc says:

    I am speechless. Are there any adults left on this fucking site? I am so tired of arguing with stupid teenagers. I am also scared to death of the future of our globe if these people are the best and the brightest of the next generation in power. Holy shit.

  2. Adrastea says:

    This is depressing.

    Just when you being to think there might be some hope for the world after all, something like this makes you realise how deeply and offensively ignorant most people really are.

    Point: Intelligent Design has absolutely zero scientific basis, and no reputable scientist would touch it with a twenty-foot barge pole. To be quite frank, the Flying Spaghetti Monster theory makes about as much sense as ID.

    I am seriously scared for the future of the human race if people who can argue in favour of ID with a straight face are going to be running the world one day.

    And please don’t generalise like that, Marc. I’m sixteen, but I’m certainly not going to be taken in by ID – as it happens I’m actively opposed to it.

    ~Adra

  3. Adrastea says:

    Oh, and one more thing:

    Intelligent Design is not a fact, and even the person who originally posted this hate mail is inadvertently admitting to it. You do not believe in facts – you don’t need to because you know them to be true.

    Or, to re-state: “I don’t believe in science. Believing in science is like believing in the postman – I don’t have to believe because I know he’s there and doing his job. Believing in religion is more like believing in Santa – you have to believe in lieu of any sort of hard evidence.”

    ~Adra

  4. IJ says:

    If we came about by evolution . . .
    How does that disprove God?
    You cannot disprove a Creator. Can something come from nothing? No color, no sound, no matter, no force of nature. Where did nature’s laws come from?
    I love science and it is a beautiful, wondrous thing. I believe that some authority created all what is possible to create. I believe this because there is no reason otherwise. There is no reason for life to exist. There is no good reason we should continue toiling in this wearisome life if there is no God.

    Why would God send His only Son to die?
    The Son of God is one with God. He is God who came to the earth in the form of man.

    Why would He create sinful man to begin with?
    He did not. He created a being that knew not what it meant to be good, nor did he know what it meant to be ‘bad.’ He had free will, but knew not to use it, until he ate from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. . .yet this was in God’s plan, as something would come out of it for His people.

    God created all things for His pleasure. (Revelation 4:11) Before the world has made, He predestined salvation for human kind. (Look through Ephesians chpt. 1) With this knowledge we can say that it is God’s mysterious pleasure that we, His creation, dwell with Him in perfect unity and purity. Instead of making us like the angels, to whom it is nearly impossible to turn away from God, as they witness His glory . . . we are separated. Gold cannot come about unless it is refined by the fire. This life is simply an opportunity that God has given us to show our faith. The angels envy us for that, as they cannot show their faith. We can. . . and if we accept Jesus as the Christ, the Messiah, and be baptized in His name, God’s spirit is promised to us . . . and He will rid us, if we do not reject it, of our ‘sinful nature’ that came by mortality. . . by Adam’s shortfall. . . and thus we will become immortal alongside Christ. And unlike Adam and Eve’s beginning, we will be reunited with God and know both good and evil–yet become in His likeness. We shall be pure in a wicked world. If we overcome through Him, we will reign with Him. If we thirst for righteousness, we will be filled. If we love Him, we will be with Him forevermore.

  5. aa9e4bd2574e1c2f54ac1cbff58cee1f says:

    aa9e4bd2574e1c2f54ac1cbff58cee1f…

    aa9e4bd2574e1c2f54ac1cbff58cee1f…

  6. Vaniqa says:

    Vaniqa…

    adding to my bookmarks…

  7. Govindaya says:

    I don

  8. Paanchajanyadharaaya says:

    I keep listening to the news speak about getting free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best site to get one.

Leave a Reply